When Phyrexia: All Will Be One launched in early 2023, it shook up Magic: The Gathering both in competitive play and in the collector scene. The set introduced striking treatments such as Oil Slick Raised Foils, Borderless art, and the Step-and-Compleat foiling process. These premium finishes gave iconic characters—especially Praetors and new legendary creatures—a high-end collector appeal.
Cards like Elesh Norn, Atraxa, and Sheoldred immediately drew heavy attention thanks to their lore significance and gameplay power. Add in exclusive variants only available through special bundles or collector boosters, and the set quickly became one of the most collectible Standard-era releases in years. Below are the ten most valuable cards from Phyrexia: All Will Be One.
10. Atraxa, Grand Unifier (Showcase) (Step-and-Compleat Foil) #459
Atraxa’s return in Phyrexia: All Will Be One was one of the set’s biggest highlights. The showcase version paired with Step-and-Compleat foiling adds a sleek finish that collectors chase. Atraxa’s powerful card draw ability ensures steady demand in Commander. This combination of aesthetics and utility makes it one of the most sought-after Atraxa printings.
9. Elesh Norn, Mother of Machines (Oil Slick Raised Foil) #345
Available only in the special Oil Slick Raised Foil treatment, this Elesh Norn is as rare as it is imposing. The exclusive foiling method makes it stand out from every other variant in the set. Players love it for its ability to double enter-the-battlefield triggers while shutting down opponents. That blend of rarity and power drives its premium market status.
8. Mondrak, Glory Dominus (Showcase) (Step-and-Compleat Foil) #424
Mondrak gives token decks in Commander an immediate boost, making it a fan favorite. The Showcase treatment combined with Step-and-Compleat foiling takes an already popular card and elevates its collectibility. As a parallel to the legendary Anointed Procession, it has long-term appeal across formats. Its rarity ensures collectors continue to pay close attention.
7. Vorinclex, Monstrous Raider (Concept Praetor) (Step-and-Compleat Foil) #407
The Concept Praetor designs stand out as some of the boldest art choices in Magic history. Vorinclex’s version, paired with Step-and-Compleat foiling, captures the raw power of the character. While Vorinclex first appeared in Kaldheim, this printing cemented its place as a premium collector card. With Commander utility and striking visuals, it remains highly valuable.
6. Elesh Norn, Mother of Machines (Borderless) #415
The Borderless variant shows off Elesh Norn’s full grandeur without frame distractions. While not as rare as Oil Slick or Step-and-Compleat foils, the clean art style is highly desired. Collectors love borderless treatments for their display quality, and this one is no exception. Its role as a key build-around in Commander ensures ongoing demand.
5. Atraxa, Grand Unifier (Oil Slick Raised Foil) #357
Atraxa already had immense hype thanks to its versatility across Commander archetypes. The Oil Slick Raised Foil treatment makes this version extremely scarce. Its texturing and sheen create a display-worthy finish unique to this product release. For collectors, it represents the pinnacle Atraxa printing from Phyrexia: All Will Be One.
4. Sheoldred, the Apocalypse (Concept Praetor) #435
Sheoldred’s power level was already proven before this release, dominating formats like Standard and Pioneer. The Concept Praetor variant delivers a chilling, alternate vision of the character. While not a foil, the rarity and distinct art direction keep it at the top of many collector lists. Its long-term relevance in multiple formats ensures lasting value.
3. Mondrak, Glory Dominus (Oil Slick Raised Foil) #346
This Oil Slick Raised Foil Mondrak is the definitive premium version of the card. Its rarity rivals that of Atraxa’s foil variants, and token deck enthusiasts view it as a must-have. As one of the breakout new cards from the set, it continues to hold collector demand. Its scarcity in the Oil Slick product keeps its value strong.
2. Elesh Norn, Mother of Machines (Borderless) (Step-and-Compleat Foil) #419
Combining Borderless art with the exclusive Step-and-Compleat foiling makes this Elesh Norn a grail piece. It merges gameplay dominance with the most premium treatment collectors could ask for. The foiling adds a textured look that enhances the borderless showcase design. It’s one of the rarest, most desirable versions of Elesh Norn ever printed.
1. Sheoldred, the Apocalypse (Concept Praetor) (Step-and-Compleat Foil) #436
At the top sits Sheoldred’s Concept Praetor in Step-and-Compleat foil. Already a powerhouse in multiple formats, Sheoldred commands respect both in gameplay and as a collector’s piece. The foiling enhances the haunting, skeletal design, making it a centerpiece card. Its rarity and competitive relevance put it firmly as the most valuable card from Phyrexia: All Will Be One.
Phyrexia: All Will Be One cemented itself as one of Magic’s most collectible modern sets. Between new legends like Mondrak and Atraxa and premium treatments of fan-favorite Praetors, the chase cards hold long-term appeal. Collectors and players alike continue to hunt these variants, ensuring their place among the most valuable Magic cards of the era.
Disclaimer: eBay links on this page use a referral system that helps support the content—at no extra cost to you.
