Duskmourn: House of Horror brings a chilling aesthetic to Magic: The Gathering with a focus on haunting environments, eerie characters, and psychological tension. Released in 2024, the set quickly gained traction with collectors thanks to its horror-inspired themes and striking alternate treatments. Showcase variants and premium foils, especially in Fracture and Textured finishes, have proven to be the most desirable.
The cards in this list represent the standouts—ones that players, collectors, and investors are all chasing. While gameplay impact drives some demand, most of the value here comes from rarity, treatment, and character appeal. Let’s look at the ten most valuable cards from Duskmourn: House of Horror.
10. Kaito, Bane of Nightmares #409 (Showcase) (Fracture Foil)
Planeswalkers nearly always attract attention, and Kaito in Duskmourn is no exception. The Showcase frame paired with a Fracture Foil treatment gives this card added visual depth. Kaito’s dark design fits perfectly into the horror theme, boosting its desirability among collectors. Though not the priciest, it consistently holds a place on high-end want lists.
9. Overlord of the Mistmoors #397 (Showcase) (Fracture Foil)
The Mistmoors Overlord is a legendary creature that blends gameplay strength with gothic artwork. The Showcase design adds a haunting flair, while the foil finish enhances its collectability. Players value it as both a commander option and a horror centerpiece. This balance of playability and aesthetics keeps it firmly in the top tier of Duskmourn singles.
8. Enduring Innocence #396 (Showcase) (Fracture Foil)
The Enduring cycle represents some of the most beautiful Showcase cards in the set, and Innocence is a standout. Its art contrasts the darker tones of Duskmourn with an unsettling purity. As part of a recurring theme of resilience, the card carries both flavor and collector appeal. Premium foiling pushes it into the higher-value bracket.
7. Enduring Courage #402 (Showcase) (Fracture Foil)
Enduring Courage embodies strength amid fear, and the Showcase version gives it a cinematic horror feel. The fractured foil treatment ensures each copy shimmers uniquely, adding to the sense of rarity. Collectors often target this one to complete the cycle of Enduring cards. Demand remains steady from players looking for both aesthetic appeal and deck utility.
6. Enduring Tenacity #400 (Showcase) (Fracture Foil)
Tenacity fits neatly within the Enduring cycle, carrying an aura of determination and resilience. The Showcase frame highlights its chilling theme while the foil version makes it a collector’s piece. Among the cycle, it’s a mid-range option in terms of value, yet still desirable for completing a full set. Collectors often pair it with Vitality and Curiosity for display.
5. Valgavoth, Terror Eater #407 (Showcase) (Textured Foil)
One of the more terrifying legendary creatures in Duskmourn, Valgavoth is a true centerpiece card. Its Textured Foil finish sets it apart as a high-premium chase variant. With powerful gameplay implications and a menacing presence, it stands as one of the most expensive mythics in the set. This is a card built for both display cases and competitive tables.
4. Enduring Curiosity #398 (Showcase) (Fracture Foil)
Curiosity blends the unsettling atmosphere of Duskmourn with a unique showcase design. The Fracture Foil effect makes this version especially sought after, as it enhances the eerie detail of the art. Collectors prize it not only for its cycle synergy but also for its independent visual storytelling. It continues to be one of the more expensive Enduring cycle cards.
3. Overlord of the Balemurk #401 (Showcase) (Fracture Foil)
This Overlord offers powerful battlefield presence and haunting artwork. Its Showcase printing elevates the horror design, and the foil pattern adds a ghostly shimmer. As with the Mistmoors and Hauntwoods versions, collectors chase these legendary creatures for both lore and play. Balemurk consistently ranks as one of the most valued Overlords in the set.
2. Overlord of the Hauntwoods #405 (Showcase) (Fracture Foil)
The Hauntwoods Overlord is arguably the most iconic of the legendary cycle from Duskmourn. Showcase treatment captures its looming presence while the foil version cements its premium status. Its demand is split between commander players and collectors, making it a steady chase card. Many consider it the most defining legendary of the set.
1. Enduring Vitality #404 (Showcase) (Fracture Foil)
The crown jewel of Duskmourn is Enduring Vitality in its Showcase Fracture Foil form. This card completes the cycle while standing out as the most valuable. Its balance of theme, art, and rarity drives collector demand sky-high. For many, this is the essential card to own from Duskmourn, embodying the set’s haunting beauty and market prestige.
Duskmourn: House of Horror has already carved out its place as one of Magic’s most collectible modern sets. The Showcase treatments and premium foil finishes give these cards long-term appeal, especially among players who enjoy the gothic horror theme.
Disclaimer: eBay links on this page use a referral system that helps support the content—at no extra cost to you.
