MTG Avatar cards quickly became some of the most desirable Universes Beyond releases thanks to scarce variants, character-driven artwork, and strong Commander relevance. Prices have stabilized enough post-release to reveal clear patterns in collector demand. Several cards hold value not only because of rarity but also because of their performance in competitive and casual formats.
Specialty treatments such as Borderless, Field Notes, Neon Ink, and Raised Foil dramatically influence market movement. Collector Boosters introduced some of the lowest-print treatments seen in recent MTG products, pushing top-tier cards into premium territory. This list highlights the ten MTG Avatar cards that currently sit at the top of the value curve and why they continue to outperform the rest of the set.
10. Avatar Aang (Borderless) #308
This borderless version remains a reliable seller due to Aang’s role as the premier five-color Commander in the product line. Extended artwork creates a cinematic feel that collectors gravitate toward when choosing between versions. Commander players seeking fully themed decks keep demand steady. Strong crossover appeal between MTG players and Avatar fans reinforces its long-term value.
9. Appa, Steadfast Guardian (Borderless) #316
Appa’s borderless printing gained traction once its gameplay performance in Standard and Commander became widely recognized. Flash, airbending interactions, and token generation give it flexibility across formats. The Field Notes art style adds a charming collectible angle. Its position in the market reflects steady demand from both competitive players and flavor-focused collectors.
8. Ozai, the Phoenix King (Borderless) #311
Ozai’s dramatic borderless artwork makes it a standout villain card for collectors. The design rewards decks that manipulate unspent mana, offering an engaging gameplay niche. Commander players experimenting with firebending mechanics helped support its price. Its blend of strong flavor, visual impact, and mechanical identity keeps it comfortably in the top ten.
7. Wan Shi Tong, Librarian (Borderless) #320
Wan Shi Tong remains one of the most discussed cards in the release due to its instant-speed flexibility and card advantage. Both competitive and casual formats adopted it quickly, fueling early price momentum. The Field Notes artwork further boosts its collector appeal. Its market strength comes from a balanced combination of power and scarcity.
6. Badgermole Cub (Borderless) #326
Badgermole Cub became a breakout mythic thanks to its ramp potential and synergy with creature-based mana strategies. Competitive experimentation added pressure to early supply. The borderless bestiary-style illustration gives the card a distinct collectible presence. Its rising value reflects both gameplay potential and artistic appeal.
5. Katara, the Fearless (Borderless) (Neon Ink Foil) #361
Katara’s Neon Ink version represents one of the rarest treatments in the entire release. Neon blue accents create a striking visual identity that differs from the standard borderless artwork. Limited print availability makes this variant a strong target for long-term collectors. Character popularity ensures that supply remains quickly absorbed whenever copies surface.
4. Fire Lord Zuko (Borderless) (Neon Ink Foil) #360
Zuko’s Neon Ink card climbs higher due to intense fan interest and extremely limited distribution. The neon red highlights reinforce the character’s firebending theme, making this one of the most visually cohesive Neon Ink cards. Collectors seeking character-accurate treatments frequently prefer this version. Scarcity combined with fandom strength maintains its elevated price.
3. Toph, the First Metalbender (Borderless) (Neon Ink Foil) #362
Toph’s Neon Ink foil consistently ranks among the hardest to find in near-mint condition. The neon green color pairing suits her metalbending motif and helps distinguish it within the cycle. Her strong fanbase drives demand well beyond gameplay use. Supply remains thin enough that prices have stayed firmly in the upper tier.
2. Aang, Swift Savior (Borderless) (Neon Ink Foil) #359
This Neon Ink version of Aang commands near-top pricing due to extreme scarcity and franchise relevance. Commander players already value the base card, and the Neon Ink foil elevates it to chase-card status. The artwork’s glowing accents give it a premium collectible identity. Enthusiasts assembling full Neon Ink sets consistently drive demand upward.
1. Avatar Aang (Raised Foil) #363
The Raised Foil treatment of Avatar Aang stands as the most valuable card in the entire MTG Avatar lineup. Textured foil layers and ultra-limited distribution position it as a flagship collectible. As the strongest five-color Commander of the set, gameplay relevance further amplifies interest. Its multi-thousand-dollar market value reflects unparalleled scarcity and cross-fanbase appeal.
These rankings show how scarcity, character appeal, and unique treatments shaped the early MTG Avatar market. As supply settles and demand continues to evolve, these cards are positioned to remain the most desirable pieces from the entire collaboration.
Disclaimer: eBay links on this page use a referral system that helps support the content—at no extra cost to you.
